12
Sep
07

My Long Ass Kanye West “Graduation” Review- Kanye Day Part 2


Props to XXLmag.com for the image.

While the opening track is titled “Good Morning (Intro),” it should be titled “Abstract” as KanYe paints a picture of his third album’s concept – himself.

“Mr. West, Mr. Fresh/Mr. by-his-self-he-so-impressed” opens the album by making fun of himself with lyrics that may seem comical, but they are layered words reflecting on his musical experience stating that “And yes, barely pass any and every class/Lookin’ at every ass/Cheated on every test/I guess this is my dissertation/Homie, this shit is basic/Welcome to graduation.” Believe it or not, this is a humble Kanye West stating that he should have been a failure, but he STILL received his diploma, like a “fly Malcolm X/buy any jeans necessary.”

Kanye is implying that his career has been judged by what he SHOULD do versus what he actually did. The industry had a strict curriculum for success – a cookie cutter formula that would make every hip-hop artist a valedictorian. “Look at the valedictorian scared of the future/While I hop in the Delorean/Scared-to-face-the-world complacent career student/Some people graduate, but be still stupid/They tell you read this, eat this, don’t look around.” As a paradox, Kanye sampled Elton John’s “Someone Saved My Life” implying that he saved hip-hop with his music by not aiming to be the valedictorian (or cookie cutter formula) and STILL graduated with Rosie Perez Ds on his report card.

This first track is your warning, if you don’t want know more about Kanye – turn off the CD.

Musically, Kanye continues to evolve by providing a timeless hip-hop sound with meaningful, classic samples (and expensive – Daft Punk and Steely Dan aren’t cheap!) with layered production and unique instruments that tell a story as much as his lyrics. Once again, Kanye is reflecting his life through his music and making his musical mentors – No ID & Jon Brion – proud. Each song has a timeless hook, astounding vocal production, and unique, yet subtle instruments that on every listen a new discovery is made. In a recent interview, Kanye stated that he had to focus on vocal production because while opening for the Rolling Stones, the white audience couldn’t sing along to all his heavy content within his music.

Despite his “poor grades,” Kanye’s astounding work experience is displayed by creating music that you can sing along to – but with a message. “Cant Tell Me Nothing” is as addictive as a “Superman Dat Hoe” (without the dance moves, of course) with lyrics like “La,la,la,la wait till I get my money right/la, la, la, la then you cant tell me nothing right.” On “I Wonder,” he pauses between each word so you can sing along or on Reecie’s favorite “Good Life,” where he slows it down, so you can sing along with T-Pain during the hook.

I digress, but can we talk about the genius “Good Life”? This is Kanye’s mockery of hip-hop’s valedictorian – his (better) answer to the current trend of popular hip-hop music using the instruments, styles, trends, and artist (T-Pain) while answering critics taking that the sampling the chipmunk soul is past trend. He speeds up Michael Jackson’s “PYT” to where it’s a melody and he is rapping to the melody of PYT!!! How crazy is that?!! Lyrically, Kanye is bragging more than ever…but rather than telling people what he owns (or rents…as most hip-hop artists do), he talks about his luxuries through his hard work. He even twists around 50 Cent’s lyrics – “50 told me go ‘head switch the style up/And if they hate then let ‘em hate/And watch the money pile up, the good life.” 50 looks like a fool for not following his own advice, especially during this 50 vs. Kanye battle, because 50 has not changed his style up and he has obviously struggled stacking up funds (the recent flops at G-Unit and 50 releasing 5 videos for “Curtis” and soon enough, he will not outsell Kanye in the first week).

While the introspective Kanye dedicates his album to his “cocky humble” complicated character, we are left without a “bigger picture” song. The CD lacks an “All Falls Down,” “Jesus Walks,” “Crack Music,” and “Diamonds from Sierra Leone,” where Kanye gambles his stardom for issues that the “everyday person” worries about but doesn’t discuss. Kanye’s approach is that of a preacher where he talks about his own past experiences to help that the listener learns about themselves.

On the “cocky humble” masterpiece “Everything I Am,” Kanye cockily expresses “that haters, start your engines /I hear ‘em gearin’ up / people talk so much shit about me at barbershops ” with a humble hook that states “everybody sayin’ what’s not for him everything I’m not, made me everything I am” while staying on topic with Kanye “spaz out at his shows /so say goodbye to the NAACP award /goodbye to the In-di-a Arie award /they’d rather give me the nigga-please award /but I’ll just take the I-got-alotta-cheese award.” Kanye makes a strong point that people may not always recognize your influence, but if you continue to “do you” then you will succeed.

While the album is extremely enjoyable and I think it will be considered a classic five years from now (even five months from now), I understand how some people (and critics) may call this Kanye’s “weakest” effort (which is crazy because his “weakest effort” is better than 95% of hip-hop releases, but the bar is set so high for Kanye) because the entire album focuses on Kanye. Even on the Jay-Z dedicated “Big Brother,” while he is talking about Jay-Z, he is only focusing on himself and his feelings…not once did he attempted to explain why Jay did what he did. Despite that, I still think the song is just as powerful as “Last Call” off his debut. If you are not a fan of Kanye or if you already think he is a cocky son-of-a-bitch, then you may not want to buy this album.

Call me petty, but while this is Kanye’s stronger lyrical effort (and I ALWAYS thought that Kanye was a passionate lyricist), some of the lyrics on the album are not as strong as Kanye claims (are we surprised?). For instance, the entire second verse of “Stronger” is a let down, especially with such amazing production and an amazing first verse. Anything for a blond dike? We can do better. Also, how can you not laugh at the “snakes on a plane” line on “Good Life” or the “Spouse/Blouse/Aroused” line in “I Wonder.” But then again – lines like those make us either love Kanye or hate him…

Kanye once said that he wants every album to be an experience, similar to a movie. If that’s the case, then call Kanye West the Peter Jackson of hip-hop as the underdog he crafted the Lord of the Rings Trilogy with his first three albums. It’s good to have an artist that looks as every album release as an opportunity to challenge his fan base, while enjoying great music. Now, that Kanye has graduated…I wonder when will he get his “Good Ass Job”?

What are your thoughts about the album? Do you think it is Kanye’s weakest effort? Do you miss the lack of the “bigger picture” song? What do you think of the production? Post your review


10 Responses to “My Long Ass Kanye West “Graduation” Review- Kanye Day Part 2”


  1. 1 Stallion September 12, 2007 at 1:23 pm

    You’re right this is a long ass review but a great one.

  2. 2 Mr. Scales September 12, 2007 at 1:59 pm

    i think it’s kanye’s best effort… i think each album he gave his best at that time, and this is that. (i dont compare albums, times change, people change) but i was more excited to buy this album then college dropout just because of the artist he has become… i went to his concert around college dropout and it was 22 dollars, now he rocks stadiums…

    i wish more songs would have made the album like bittersweet, goodnight, and that joint with mos def that is on the international release, etc…

    but what i love about kanye the artist, is that he does music for himself and just hopes the world loves it, not the other way around

    so im G.O.O.D. it inspires me to write more, chase dreams, question life, have strong beliefs, and enjoy every minute

    i think drunk and hot girls is weak.

    album is short but so dope

    i hope now more artist put themselves into records, not just what they think will generate sales

  3. 3 Reecie September 12, 2007 at 2:15 pm

    Well we’ve already battled it out over Graduation…but I have to say that this is a great review! But to add…

    This album is more than just an album all about Kanye, it’s a personal work of art. Sometimes the best way to relate to others is through self-reflection. So many people lack the ability to examine the good and the bad about themselves…thus preventing any real opportunity for growth. Every Kanye album doesn’t sound the same…because every album captures a different moment in time (he spoke on this a little on 106 & Park). It’s obvious in his lyrics that he is very critical of his work and conscious at all times about its quality and the messages he puts out there. Perhaps if more artists did the same thing, then people would always look forward to something new rather than a rehash of the same formulas.

    Personally speaking…my college graduation period was a time where I stopped focusing on how I thought I was being perceived and really took a deep hard look at myself. I learned how to define myself for myself rather than being on the defensive about people’s perceptions. I think more than any other time in my life, I learned how to really embrace the good and make that my focus. I kinda got that kind of vibe from Kanye from this album. Graduation is more of a “take me as I am”/celebratory album…he is happy with his success and he’s unapologetic about his flaws (yet humbled by them at the same time).

    If you really think about it…just about everything on this album is a celebration of how far he has come. Going back to “barely passed any and every class” to hopping in the delorean…regardless of how he got there (i.e. the struggles outlined in Big Brother)…in his eyes he has finally made it to the point to where he has solidified his credibility. Good Morning, Champion, Stronger, I Wonder, Good Life, Can’t Tell Me Nothing, Barry Bonds, Everything I Am, The Glory, Homecoming, Big Brother…every last one of those songs is a celebration…and that’s why this album makes people feel good. Every song is an anthem that people can take with them in their personal lives and say this song captures that feeling when I graduated from college, or got my first career job, or bought my new car, or whatever. This is feel good music…and once you take Kanye out of the picture and put yourself in these lyrics you will see just how easily anyone can relate.

  4. 4 Mr Styles September 12, 2007 at 2:56 pm

    I concur

  5. 5 redshade07 September 12, 2007 at 2:57 pm

    The suspense is killing me…waiting on damn Kmart to get shipments, otherwise I’m cutting school and having a friend take me to the mall.

  6. 6 senoje September 12, 2007 at 3:23 pm

    Album is great. I play it just about every morning, and it gets me pumped as I begin my day. My favorite tracks keep changing.. the more I read into the lyrics and pickup on the lyrics… but my first favorite song was “I wonder…” I like the good life as well, and I like bright lights now… its tough because I want to just stick with one song. But as it grows on me, its sort of like an evolution, what I originally thought I liked was simply because of the catchy word play and the melody, has changed into a more introspective look, on what exactly I can trully relate to. I appreciate this album… so much that I play it on my laptop, ripped it to my my treo, and I listen to it as I walk to class.

  7. 7 viciuzurban September 12, 2007 at 11:04 pm

    wow

  8. 8 Thesis September 13, 2007 at 5:48 am

    thehonorable-
    well-thought out and honest review brotha. if your review was long, what does that say about mine? lol

  9. 9 P.DID'nt September 15, 2007 at 8:36 am

    Words cannot do it justice… I am Speechless… I am without speech…

    Im from Sydney Australia and well I grew up listening to hip hop and slowly listened to it become commercially corrupted… But I never gave up hope that their was more and more G.O.O.D music out there…

    And actually on Friday before the album was released all day at work for me it was “KanYe West Appreciation DaY” - where I made sure everyone aware to support G.O.O.D music and buy “Graduation” (I even got everyone to throw their Diamonds Up -old folk included)…

    It was JayZ’s “Blueprint” and the work of KanYe and Just Blaze that got me right back into Hip Hop (and got me and my brother into producing Hip Hop)… and since “College Dropout” Ye has been one of those artists who anything he releases is in the “Instant Buy” category…

    And I behaved myself on for this album… Reecie you would be impressed at the lengths I actually went to to avoid hearing anything from “Graduation” just so I could have that perfect experience on the day I purchased it.

    Every song was a different experience… AND who was it that once told KanYe that he couldnt rap???? WTF is up with that…

    Btw anyone else hear “Drunk & Hot Girls” feat. Mos Def??? coz I noticed that it wasn’t on the American release… BUT that song is f**kin HOT… not to mention quite comical…

    I could go on and on and on all night talking bout it…

    PEACE, n much love
    P.DID’nt

  10. 10 MC Esprit October 4, 2007 at 11:18 pm

    Also from Australia,

    Am now 30+… from well Melbourne and surrounds. Used to listen to hip-hop mid to late 90’s. Only a few artists I have thought are worth buying post 90’s as most has turned or comes out as lolly-pop/ candy bar rubbish selling out to impressionable teens who are eager to spend cash on the latest crap. Keeps up soon they won’t know any better. If I do listen to hip-hop I will listen to 90’s or Jay-Z and K West who have been the only 2 I know of that have been worth buying. Both have excellent production that doesn’t appear to overflow with sell-out-ness. Btw Heavy D did keep it real despite immense outside pressure (assuming) and I also enjoyed his style very much.

    Back to today… lyrically Jay-Z is a master, and West is simply nice to listen to, almost as nice as hearing Warren G’s regulate back in the day, just a great voice to sit back and take in. I wonder whether lyrically KW is running out of steam on some tracks. Although he has brough fresh production, I think it has a commercial feel to it even if not intended. Drunk and hot girls is awful, worst track on the album that makes me think he is selling out to be ‘cool’ simply by having such a track (subject matter) regardless of the lyrics. Either way I still think it’s the worst song he’s done. Yet “Going Home” which reminds me of Nas’ Money is My Bitch (1999) but lyrically less impressive has a tune that I can’t get enough of and keep repeating it over and over. On the whole Graduation somewhat impresses me but I remain unsure. As I don’t listen to hip-hop everyday these days I may be missing a lot of the lyrical subtleties. And I certainly remain open to criticism, however this is my general feel of the album, his first still stands high above all three. I’d give this 7 out of 10, his first 9.5 and his second 7 also. I really haven’t analysed this enough and lack being up with hip-hop these days to be able to recognise some double-meanings which may raise my impressions of his lyrics. My final point is that K.West is one of few that at least keeps an ol’ school hip-hop afficionado listening to hip-hop post 2000, but I hope his next is a tad better.

    Cheers.


Honorable Media:

The latest Hip Hop and R&B Soul music updates, gossip, TV and movie reviews, politics, discussion, and more!


Contributors:


Reecie


thehonorable

Categories

Archives